Finder’s Archives – Managing Expectations —

Lately, I’ve been seeing a lot of discussions of how Game Masters deal with player expectations for a campaign, and I wanted to share a few tips and ideas on how to manage this. So here are a few tools that I’ve had luck with in the past.

Pre-plan and advise:

This sounds more complicated than it is, but it basically boils down to explaining to the players what the campaign is going to be about. Sort of like an “Ok guys, this particular campaign will be a mid-level (5-10) campaign, set in a gothic horror version of New England – expect low magic, low combat, and lots of Cthulhu Mythos insanity and it’ll be played using FATE.”

This allows the players to at least get a general idea of what you’re planning so that they don’t show up with widely different ideas of what’s going to happen.

The Opening Crawl:

Stolen directly from the Edge of the Empire Beginner Game, this turned out to be a great tool for setting up the beginning of the scenario and giving the players an idea of the current lay of the land. This allows everyone to get an idea of what’s going to happen as well, critically without investing more “live-time” on the GM’s part. So while they’re watching the Opening Crawl, he can get ready for the adventure.

Session 0:

Session 0 is a concept that many groups have been experimenting with. It’s a “non-game” session in which the player characters are created, and discussed so that each character can fill a dynamic role within the gaming group, and each player has a chance to connect his character with the rest of the members of the party. This is also an opportunity to roleplay certain interactions between characters, if these are baked into the system (such as the Star Trek Character Creation – reviewed by Linda Whitson HERE), allowing the players to get more of a feel for both their own character and the other members of the party.

Level 0/Character Funnel:

This is something that Dungeon Crawl Classics has pioneered, and it is a game type/entry point, that I’m a huge fan of. Essentially each player gets 4 random characters, all 0-level and all randomly generated with stats, a background occupation, a weapon and a flavorful piece of equipment (a barrow full of manure anyone?). These 4 characters are then thrown into an adventure, together with each of the OTHER players’ 4 characters, leaving you with a party of anywhere between 16 and 24 characters (4-6 players). The ones that survive, those are your characters for the campaign.

This automatically gives the PCs a sense of belonging within the party, and a reason to work together, along with an incredible tale of survival (“It was a slaughter. Everyone died, except us 4.”).

Managing and finding time:

One thing that many groups find difficult is quite simply to coordinate the gaming group. There is, unfortunately, no great way to fix this. Instead, simply try to keep your game on the same gameday each time, starting at the same time. And make sure everyone is reminded in a timely fashion (and OFTEN) so that no other issues get in the way. There are many ways to coordinate, from Evernote, Gmail calendars, and others. Simply use the one that fits your group the best, and which you can get everyone to use on a regular basis.

And what about you?

What do you and your group use to try and manage expectations and time?

The following two tabs change content below.

Kim Frandsen

40 years old, and a gamer since I was 13. These days I freelance as a writer for various companies (currently Fat Goblin Games, Flaming Crab Games, Outland Entertainment, Paizo, Raging Swan Games, Rusted Iron Games, and Zenith Games), I've dipped my hands into all sorts of games, but my current "go-to" games are Pathfinder 2, Dungeon Crawl Classics and SLA Industries. Unfortunately, while wargaming used to be a big hobby, with wife, dog and daughter came less time.

Latest posts by Kim Frandsen (see all)

1 Comment

  1. Setting the stage for players is Key, if your not clear on what kind of game your running you will have lots of people with characters they might not necessarily enjoy playing in that campaign. So usually when someones character is off or not fitting with the game I find it was because GM wasn’t clear bout what the players can expect. Usually 😉

    I have one player who GM’s infrequently but when he does his audio visual displays are amazing, music and all usually a intro or reintro to where you have been or where you are.

    In the past as a GM I have gone a group recap together and asked questions before running the opening crawl (great tool btw)

    More visual aids really help show the players even if your doing theatre of the mind its nice to give players a visual que or two.

    Session 0 and character creation together is another must have with your group. I use backstory cards which are great for creating player background associations. http://www.drivethrurpg.com/product/138416/Backstory-Cards

    The bane of almost all groups is game scheduling however much like yourself I find that if I keep it consistent people are able to plan for it and come.

Comments are closed.